An engineering critical assessment determines the maximum allowable flaw-size for known materials in all construction and operating conditions.





Examples of where ECA has been applied include:
  • Dynamic riser systems, which are fatigue-sensitive structures
  • Steel catenary risers, which are also fatigue-sensitive structures
  • Time-sensitive onshore and offshore pipeline-construction projects where high-productivity welding processes and automated ultrasonic testing (AUT) of weld quality are used
Welding fabrication codes specify maximum tolerable flaw-sizes and minimum tolerable charpy-energy level based on good workmanship. Achieving these standards, however, does not ensure that a certain minimum risk tolerance has been obtained.
Engineering critical assessment (ECA) is an analysis based on the principles of fracture mechanics to determine if a given material (with known properties) with certain flaw characteristics can resist fracture, fatigue, creep or plastic collapse under specified loading conditions.
 Applus+ ECA can be used to:
  • Assist in the choice of welding procedure and/or inspection technique during the design phase of an installation
  • Assess the significance of known defects that are unacceptable for the given fabrication code
  • Detect a failure to meet the toughness requirements of a fabrication code
  • Assess flaws found in–service and decision-making regarding their disposition (safely remain, down rate component/repair required)
The application of ECA requires a multi-disciplinary team and hinges on three parameters: stresses acting on the region of the flaw; size, position and orientation of the flaw; and toughness and tensile properties in the region of the flaw. Applus+ offers specialist capabilities in all of these three areas.
The in-depth stress-analysis consultation services provided by Applus+ offer clients key information about their assets where they need it most.